fbpx
Search
Close this search box.

Got Muck?

Sometimes the best “tool in the toolbox” is to leave some of the muck right where it is, especially if onsite wetland preservation is needed.

The scarcity of Florida’s buildable land has developers turning to parcels they previously passed over because they contained thick layers of muck. Muck (wet, sticky soil made from decaying plant material) presents several challenges for developers, including:

  1. it normally indicates a wetland is present that needs permitting and mitigation,
  2. it is geotechnically unsuitable for building upon, and
  3. it can contain arsenic in concentrations above residential standards.

In this article, we will specifically address the arsenic problem.

Arsenic is typically present in muck for a combination of reasons; some natural and some anthropogenic (human-caused). A primary source of anthropogenic arsenic is the use of herbicides like monosodium methyl arsenate (MSMA). An important first step is to determine what portion is naturally occurring and what portion is anthropogenic.  Although any arsenic above cleanup target levels needs to be managed to protect human health, if it is naturally occurring, arsenic generally can be managed safely onsite without the need for deed restrictions (which can lower property values). A well-crafted soil sampling plan and some statistics can usually distinguish naturally occurring arsenic from anthropogenic arsenic.

During arsenic cleanup, another crucial step is matching the cleanup strategy with the project’s desired end result. A single development project may have multiple land uses:  single-family residential, commercial, open recreational space, assisted-living facility, conservation easement, etc. Each of these land uses may have a different cleanup target level for arsenic. The most cost-effective remedial strategy will typically address each future land use separately.

WGI Environmental

Before WGI proposes a remedial plan for arsenic, we meet with the developer (including the geotechnical engineer and the general contractor) to understand what earthwork needs to occur regardless of any arsenic remediation. What lakes need to be dug? How much soil needs to be imported or exported for grading and flood control? What earthwork needs to occur to create geotechnically stable subsoils? Then we develop a cost-effective remedial plan that incorporates the earthwork that needs to get done anyway for other site development purposes.

If active arsenic remediation is needed, WGI has a range of effective tools. In some cases, removal and offsite disposal of some “hot spots” are the most economical, followed by soil blending of the remaining muck with soil that has lower concentrations. One of our most common solutions is to over-excavate a lake (especially if the development needs a source of clean fill material) and place the muck in the bottom of the lake. A key consideration here, however, is to test the soil using the Synthetic Precipitation Leaching Procedure to ensure the arsenic will not leach out of the muck and contaminate the groundwater. Also, the environmental regulatory agencies require a comprehensive water quality assessment, including pre-construction (baseline) monitoring wells, to compare to post-construction conditions. Sometimes the best “tool in the toolbox” is to leave some of the muck right where it is, especially if onsite wetland preservation is needed. Our extensive experience shows the most cost-effective solution uses multiple tools from that toolbox.

Share this post

Share this post

Learn more
about our
services

Related

Awards

WGI Triumphs at 2024 SMPS Houston Design Awards!

WGI proudly clinched first place in the Video/Audio Media category at the 2024 SMPS Houston Design Awards for the 2023 rebrand of the WGI Unleashed podcast, showcasing our innovative marketing prowess.

Blog

Empowering the Future of AEC: WGI’s Commitment to Mentorship

Explore the role of mentorship in shaping the future of AEC professionals. Follow WGI’s Robby Vogel as he empowers students at Louisiana Tech University, bridging academia and real-world practice to cultivate the next generation of AEC innovators and leaders.

Webinar

Webinar Recap: Topographic Mapping at a Grand Scale

From the region-specific challenges to airspace access and ecological considerations, join WGI’s Geospatial Technology Specialist III, Mark Topping, for an exclusive look into the in-depth planning and cutting-edge technologies that were instrumental in crafting the highest-resolutions dataset for one of the natural wonders of the world.

Blog

Project Spotlight: Clear Lake Trail & Boardwalk (West Palm Beach, FL)

Discover how WGI seamlessly blends urban connectivity with natural conservation in the Clear Lake Trail & Boardwalk project, integrating innovative design and engineering to enhance the landscape while preserving the purity of Clear Lake, West Palm Beach’s primary drinking water source.

Blog

Event Recap: Texas Water 2024

Dive into the enriching experience of the 2024 Texas Water Conference, where innovation, collaboration, and networking converge in shaping the future of the water and wastewater industry.

JOIN THE TEAM

You’ve been searching for a place like WGI. We look forward to meeting you soon.

We're
Nearby

Enter your zip code, and we’ll personalize your experience with local projects, office locations, team members, and more.

WGI's success starts with our Associates

WGI supports its associates with meaningful opportunities for growth, strong benefits and perks, while we work collaboratively with clients and co-consultants to shape and improve communities.

Our Team in Action

Join the Team

WGI is a dynamic organization with opportunities nationwide for engineers, land surveyors, landscape architects, environmental scientists, and architects.

Find a team member:

Let's talk about your next project.