Fire protection systems can help manage or extinguish fire, aid in occupant evacuation, and help protect property from damage. These systems can be separated into two categories: active fire protection (AFP) and passive fire protection (PFP).  AFP systems require a trigger action to function, and include things like fire extinguishers, fire/smoke alarms, and sprinkler systems. PFP systems, on the other hand, include building elements such as fire and smoke rated walls and floors that are used to separate parts of the building.

As part of the passive fire protection system, fire/smoke rated partitions and barriers compartmentalize the building and prevent the spread of fire and smoke to the entire building. While penetrating these barriers with ductwork should be avoided if possible, sometimes it is necessary. In these penetrations, fire and/or smoke dampers can be utilized to maintain the fire resistance rating. There are three types of these dampers: fire dampers, smoke dampers, and combination fire/smoke dampers (FSDs).

Fire dampers are designed for the purpose of preventing the spread of flames across a rated barrier. A fire damper is installed within the duct where the duct intersects the barrier. They operate using a heat sensitive device that, when activated, melts and causes the damper components to close. A smoke damper can also be installed within the duct, and is activated by a signal from a smoke detector within the damper.  Upon detection of smoke, the actuator will automatically close the damper components. A combination fire/smoke damper will close upon detection of EITHER fire or smoke. An FSD can also contain an electric heat release device, which can be reset, and allows the damper to close in a more controlled way, rather than slamming shut when the heat sensitive device melts. FSDs will also close upon electrical power failure, as they are held open by a powered actuator. This means that they can be interlocked with the building fire alarm system such that they close after receiving a signal from the fire alarm system.

So, we know the difference. But how do we know which one to use? The simple answer is that the rating of the damper should match the rating of the barrier that it is protecting. For example, if the barrier is only rated to prevent the spread of fire, only a fire damper is required. If the barrier is rated to prevent the spread of smoke and fire, an FSD is required. FSDs are larger and more expensive than fire dampers, so they are generally only used in barriers that are fire and smoke rated.

FSDs are listed with both a fire rating and a leakage class. The mechanical code governing the area in which your building is located will determine how the FSD is selected. Below is a reference from the 2015 International Mechanical Code showing the requirements for fire and smoke dampers. Combination fire/smoke dampers must meet the requirements for both fire dampers and smoke dampers. Also shown below is an example of an FSD that would meet these requirements when installed in an assembly with less than a 3-hour fire resistance rating.

In order to properly protect a building and its occupants, the active and passive fire protection systems must work together effectively. Fire dampers, smoke dampers, and combination fire/smoke dampers are critical parts of passive fire protection systems. These elements protect buildings from property damage, and allow for proper occupant evacuation in the event of a fire emergency.

Your project needs Mechanical, Electrical, and Plumbing Engineers who have done this before. Our MEP team has completed the HVAC, electrical, and plumbing design for hundreds of apartments, office buildings, and related high-rise development projects.

Sources:

• Knapp, J. (2011, Fall). Fire Dampers and Smoke Dampers: The Difference is Important. AMCA International, 20-23.
• Passive Fire Protection vs. Active Fire Protection. (2015, July 07). Retrieved July 26, 2017, from http://news.lifesafetyservices.com/blog/active-vs-passive-fire-protection-2