The learning curve associated with adopting new technology can be a significant hurdle for many firms. Will the time and effort be worth it in the long term?
Subsurface Utility Engineering (SUE): See What’s Below, Create Savings Above
During construction activities, the lack of reliable underground utility location information can result in costly delays due to conflicts or damages, utility service disruptions, redesigns, liability claims, and injuries.
Subsurface Utility Engineering (SUE) is a specialized engineering discipline responsible for managing risks associated with below-ground utility locating and mapping, including condition assessments and construction strategies. WGI has over 20 years of experience conducting SUE investigations on behalf of our clients, resulting in time and construction cost savings, and safer construction sites.
Within the ownership and design community, the reasonable starting expectation is subsurface utility locations should exist in plans and records. However, experience often reveals that utility locations are not exactly as recorded, or that records do not fully account for additional buried utility systems or improperly documented system modifications. As a result, SUE is a solution providing vital information.
When used appropriately and performed correctly, SUE identifies existing subsurface utility data, maps underground utility locations, and classifies the data’s accuracy based on standardized quality levels. The collected SUE data allows for developing strategies and making informed design decisions, managing risks, and avoiding utility conflicts and delays. If a utility conflict arises, viable alternatives can be found to resolve the issue before any physical or monetary damage is done.
Combining civil engineering, surveying, geophysics, asset-management technologies, and nondestructive excavation technologies, during the design phase, SUE provides accurate 3D mapping of existing underground utilities. This helps avoid unnecessary relocations, eliminates unexpected conflicts with utilities, and enhances safety during construction.
3D model of subsurface utilities and structures, Pierce Avenue, Godfrey, IL.
With ever-advancing technologies, the SUE industry and standards have the capabilities to produce deliverables in a 3-D modeling format as shown here. With more data comes better design and construction abilities.
Utilizing SUE services is now a routine requirement on U.S. highway and bridge design projects, strongly advocated by the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), American Society of Civil Engineers, American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials, and state departments of transportation.
Used extensively in highway design and construction for 25+ years, SUE is gaining strong endorsement by many other client markets. Over a decade ago, the U.S. Federal
Aviation Administration released a DVD to its industry, titled, “Underground Update,” to explain the benefits of SUE. The U.S. military also endorses SUE for use in designing construction projects that involve congested underground utilities.
In the past decade, we’ve seen many more private land developers take advantage of our SUE services in their complex urban infill projects. Private-sector projects find an appropriate level of SUE investigation is very beneficial during the entitlement and design phases.
During construction, accurate SUE information also expedites excavation and installation, saving time and right-of-way rental fees. In dense, urban environments featuring multi-story buildings effectively built up to their lot lines, the adjacent rights-of-way become very congested with underground utilities. In downtown areas, it is not uncommon to find large stormwater drainage pipes, chilled water lines, fiberoptic data lines, wastewater and water pipes, natural gas lines, and electric infrastructure all contained in the same cross-section. The presence of these public utilities increases the potential for utility conflicts both during design and especially during construction.
An FHWA-sponsored study found that $4.62 was saved on overall project costs for every $1 spent on SUE. This figure was quantified by a study of 71 projects with a combined construction value in excess of $1B. Qualitative savings were not measurable, but clearly those savings were also significant, perhaps exponentially more valuable than the quantifiable savings.
Close to two decades ago, the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) published the Standard Guideline for the Collection and Depiction of Existing Subsurface Utility Data (38-02). It formally defines SUE and sets standard guidance for collecting and depicting underground utility information.
The ASCE standard elevated SUE’s importance, presenting a subsurface utility data classification system that organized it into quality levels. Project owners, land surveyors, engineers, and construction contractors can determine a project’s suitable quality level at an appropriate cost, strategically reducing or allocating risks due to existing subsurface utilities. The standard closely follows concepts in place in the industry. Owners, engineers, and surveyors can maintain their compliance with this standard using SUE, or through their inclusion of SUE specifications in their engineering and surveying contracts.
QUALITY LEVELS FOR THE SUE PROCESS
The three major activities of designating, locating, and managing data are conducted individually to meet a given project’s specific needs. However, they are most advantageously employed in combination, creating a utility system’s complete 3D mapping. While the practice of SUE is tailored to each project, the ensuing process typically follows these ASCE Quality Levels:
Quality Level D Is the least-detailed SUE deliverable available. In Level D, the SUE
provider gathers utility records (as-built drawings, field notes, distribution maps) from
all available sources. All data is then compiled into a composite drawing and labeled ASCE Quality Level D.
Quality Level C A survey is performed of all visible surface features of the existing underground utilities (e.g., manholes, pedestals, valves, etc.). This information is added to the composite drawing completed during the ASCE Quality Level D record research and upgraded to ASCE Quality Level C.
Quality Level B Utilities designation using a variety of geophysical techniques (e.g., pipe and cable locators, or ground-penetrating radar), determining the utilities’ horizontal position. This information is surveyed, then compiled into the utility drawing, now labeled as ASCE Quality Level B data.
Quality Level A Is the most detailed and invasive SUE quality level. Once conflicts are identified, the data collection process’s final step is excavating test holes at key locations where the utilities’ exact size, material type, depth, and orientation are identified through vacuum excavation. The test hole information is surveyed and included in the utility drawings, which are now ASCE Quality Level A.
Cross Section of SUE Field Collection
There is tremendous advantage and value to knowing with certainty the location of potentially impacted utilities — at the planning stage, prior to contract bidding, and field mobilization. For maximum effectiveness, the SUE process should be incorporated early in the development of every project that may impact underground utility facilities — especially in urban areas.
When subsurface utilities are discovered during the construction phase, both the conflict resolution costs and the potential for catastrophic damages are at their highest. That is what makes the collection and systematic depiction of reliable data for existing subsurface utilities so critical. Engineers can make informed decisions and support risk-management protocols during their design process.
WGI Can Help
WGI’s SUE experts will help you avoid costly conflicts, damages, delays, utility service
disruptions, redesigns, claims, injuries, and even lost lives.
For more information about these topics or to have a conversation with one of our experts, please contact us:
Share this post
Share this post
Meet our Awesome Associate Coleen Johnson, a Regional Survey Manager in our Austin, Texas office. She is a Texas Registered Professional Land Surveyor with 30+ years of experience.
WGI makes a very significant 41-spot jump from last year’s Hot Firm ranking of #76.
WGI Associates Bob Hanson, Eric Mathews, and Jim Sullivan attended the MAPPS 2019 Federal Programs Conference and Capitol Hill Day in Alexandria, VA.
The list identifies key players in the local real estate market who power what remains a significant driver in the South Florida economy.
WGI is proud to welcome three Geospatial leaders as we expand our operations across the country.